When it comes to keeping your garage door looking good and working well, damaged panels can be a big headache. While replacing a garage door panel might seem like a quick fix, it’s not always simple or affordable. Let’s walk through everything you need to know about garage door panel replacement, including when it works, when it doesn’t, and what your other options might be.
What is a Garage Door Panel Replacement?
A garage door panel replacement is when you change out one or more sections of your garage door without replacing the whole thing. It sounds like an easy job, but that isn’t always the case.
- Panels can be damaged by bumps, rust, weather, or wear and tear.
- You might want a replacement to fix dents or cracks.
- Some people try to replace a panel to save money instead of buying a whole new door.
But here’s the deal: sometimes replacing just one panel costs more time, stress, and money than you’d think.
Why Panel Replacement Can Be More Expensive
Let’s break down the reasons replacing a garage door panel can actually cost more than a new door:
- Hard to Find Matching Panels
Garage doors aren’t one-size-fits-all. If your door is old or custom, finding a perfect match is tough.
- Your panel might no longer be made.
- Paint and finish fade with time, making new parts stick out.
- Even if the design is close, small details like grooves or edges may not line up.
- Labor Costs Add Up
Replacing a panel takes precision. Installers need to remove the damaged part without messing up the rest of the door.
- The opener, springs, and tracks might also need adjusting.
- If the structure behind the panel is damaged, that needs fixing too.
- Labor rates for garage door services vary, but they add up quickly—especially if the job isn’t straightforward.
- Risk of Hidden Damage
If your panel is broken from a bump or crash, other parts may be bent or stressed.
- A hit to the bottom panel can throw off the whole balance.
- Even small cracks can affect insulation and security.
- The more damage there is behind the scenes, the more expensive repairs become.
- You Might Need More Than One Panel
Sometimes, replacing just one doesn’t work. If two or more are damaged, it can cost nearly the same as a full replacement.
- Sections may not line up properly.
- Older doors with brittle materials might crack further during the fix.
- Color Matching Issues
Even if you find the right panel model, matching the color can be impossible.
- Sun exposure fades paint over time.
- A brand-new panel next to old ones can be an eyesore.
- Repainting all panels for a match raises the total cost.
There are times when replacing a panel makes perfect sense. If these boxes are checked, it could be a smart move:
- Only one panel is damaged.
- Your door is still in production.
- The replacement panel is available and affordable.
- The damage is cosmetic, not structural.
- Your panel matches the others in design and finish.
If all of that lines up, you could save a good amount by doing a panel swap.
Keep in mind: it’s best to act fast. The longer you wait, the harder it is to find a matching panel, especially if your garage door model is discontinued.
When It's Better to Replace the Whole Door
Sometimes, the best option is to start fresh. Here’s when a full garage door replacement makes more sense:
- Multiple panels are damaged or cracked.
- The door is older and replacement parts are unavailable.
- There are issues with insulation, hardware, or the opener.
- You want a modern look or better energy efficiency.
- You’re already planning other home upgrades.
A new garage door can improve curb appeal, make your home quieter, and even lower your energy bills. Many of today’s garage doors are built with better insulation, weather sealing, and safety features.
Cost Breakdown: Panel vs. Full Replacement
To help you decide, here’s a closer look at typical costs:
Panel Replacement:
One standard steel panel: $250–$750
Custom wood or insulated panel: $400–$1,000+
Paint matching: $100–$300
Labor: $150–$300
Full Garage Door Replacement:
Non-insulated single garage door: $900–$1,300
Insulated steel door: $1,400–$2,200
Custom wood or carriage style: $2,500–$10,000+
Labor and disposal included in many installs
So, while a single panel might be less expensive up front, replacing more than one panel could bring you very close to full replacement territory.
Other Things to Think About
Before making your decision, think about:
Age of Your Garage Door
If your door is more than 10-15 years old, a full replacement gives you a fresh start.Efficiency and Insulation
Modern doors are better sealed and keep your garage more comfortable year-round.Warranty Coverage
Panel replacements might not be covered under older warranties. A new door often comes with full coverage.Curb Appeal and Home Value
A new door can boost your home’s curb appeal and may even raise its resale value. Real estate studies show garage door replacements have a great return on investment.
Tips for a Smooth Replacement Process
Want to make things go smoothly? Here’s what you can do:
Take photos of the damage before calling a pro.
Write down the model number of your garage door if available.
Get multiple quotes from licensed professionals.
Ask about warranties on parts and labor.
Consider upgrading if your opener is outdated too.
Being informed helps you save money and avoid headaches.
Can you just replace the panels on a garage door?
Yes, but only if the panel matches your existing door in size, style, and design.
How much does it cost to replace one garage door panel?
It typically costs between $400 and $1,500, depending on material, labor, and finish.
Can you buy just one section of a garage door?
Yes, if your door’s manufacturer still makes that exact model and panel.
Are garage door panels universal?
No, garage door panels are not universal—they vary by brand, size, and style.
At OHD Company Bellingham, we’ve seen it all—from cracked panels to complete overhauls. We’ll take a close look at your garage door and help you figure out the smartest path forward.
- Need just a single panel? We’ll track it down if it’s still available.
- Need a full door? We’ve got lots of stylish, energy-efficient options.
Call (360) 734-5960 today to get started with a professional inspection. We’ll walk you through the options and give you a free estimate.
Contact us today—let’s get that garage door looking great again!
